第 30 节
作者:不落的滑翔翼      更新:2021-03-11 18:42      字数:9322
  37。  By altering his arrangements and changing his plans;
  'Wang Hsi thinks that this means not using the same
  stratagem twice。'
  he keeps the enemy without definite knowledge。
  'Chang Yu;  in a quotation from another work;  says:   〃The
  axiom;  that war is based on deception; does not apply only to
  deception of the enemy。  You must deceive even your own soldiers。
  Make them follow you; but without letting them know why。〃'
  By shifting his camp and taking circuitous routes;  he prevents
  the enemy from anticipating his purpose。
  38。  At the critical moment; the leader of an army acts like
  one who has climbed up a height and then kicks away the ladder
  behind him。  He carries his men deep into hostile territory
  before he shows his hand。
  'Literally; 〃releases the spring〃 (see V。 ss。 15); that is;
  takes some decisive step which makes it impossible for the army
  to returnlike Hsiang Yu; who sunk his ships after crossing a
  river。  Ch‘en Hao; followed by Chia Lin; understands the words
  less well as 〃puts forth every artifice at his command。〃'
  39。  He burns his boats and breaks his cooking…pots; like a
  shepherd driving a flock of sheep; he drives his men this way and
  that; and nothing knows whither he is going。
  'Tu Mu says:   〃The army is only cognizant of orders to
  advance or retreat;  it is ignorant of the ulterior ends of
  attacking and conquering。〃'
  40。  To muster his host and bring it into danger:this may
  be termed the business of the general。
  'Sun Tzu means that after mobilization there should be no
  delay in aiming a blow at the enemy's heart。  Note how he returns
  again and again to this point。  Among the warring states of
  ancient China; desertion was no doubt a much more present fear
  and serious evil than it is in the armies of today。'
  41。  The different measures suited to the nine varieties of
  ground;
  'Chang Yu says:  〃One must not be hide…bound in interpreting
  the rules for the nine varieties of ground。'
  the expediency of aggressive or defensive tactics;  and the
  fundamental laws of human nature:  these are things that must
  most certainly be studied。
  42。  When invading hostile territory; the general principle
  is;  that penetrating deeply brings cohesion; penetrating but a
  short way means dispersion。
  'Cf。 supra; ss。 20。'
  43。  When you leave your own country behind; and take your
  army across neighborhood territory; you find yourself on critical
  ground。
  'This 〃ground〃 is curiously mentioned in VIII。 ss。 2; but it
  does not figure among the Nine Situations or the Six Calamities
  in chap。 X。  One's first impulse would be to translate it distant
  ground;〃 but this; if we can trust the commentators; is precisely
  what is not meant here。  Mei Yao…ch‘en says it is 〃a position not
  far enough advanced to be called 'facile;' and not near enough to
  home to be 'dispersive;' but something between the two。〃  Wang Hsi
  says:  〃It is ground separated from home by an interjacent state;
  whose territory we have had to cross in order to reach it。
  Hence;  it is incumbent on us to settle our business there
  quickly。〃   He adds that this position is of rare occurrence;
  which is the reason why it is not included among the Nine
  Situations。'
  When there are means of communication on all four sides;  the
  ground is one of intersecting highways。
  44。  When you penetrate deeply into a country; it is serious
  ground。  When you penetrate but a little way;  it is facile
  ground。
  45。  When you have the enemy's strongholds on your rear; and
  narrow passes in front; it is hemmed…in ground。  When there is no
  place of refuge at all; it is desperate ground。
  46。  Therefore; on dispersive ground; I would inspire my men
  with unity of purpose。
  'This end; according to Tu Mu; is best attained by remaining
  on the defensive; and avoiding battle。  Cf。 supra; ss。 11。'
  On facile ground; I would see that there is close connection
  between all parts of my army。
  'As Tu Mu says; the object is to guard against two possible
  contingencies:   〃(1)  the desertion of our own troops;  (2)  a
  sudden attack on the part of the enemy。〃  Cf。 VII。 ss。 17。  Mei
  Yao…ch‘en says:  〃On the march; the regiments should be in close
  touch;  in an encampment; there should be continuity between the
  fortifications。〃'
  47。  On contentious ground; I would hurry up my rear。
  'This is Ts‘ao Kung's interpretation。  Chang Yu adopts it;
  saying:   〃We must quickly bring up our rear; so that head and
  tail may both reach the goal。〃  That is; they must not be allowed
  to straggle up a long way apart。  Mei Yao…ch‘en offers another
  equally plausible explanation:  〃Supposing the enemy has not yet
  reached the coveted position; and we are behind him;  we should
  advance with all speed in order to dispute its possession。〃
  Ch‘en Hao;  on the other hand; assuming that the enemy has had
  time to select his own ground; quotes VI。 ss。 1; where Sun Tzu
  warns us against coming exhausted to the attack。  His own idea of
  the situation is rather vaguely expressed:   〃If there is a
  favorable position lying in front of you; detach a picked body of
  troops to occupy it; then if the enemy; relying on their numbers;
  come up to make a fight for it; you may fall quickly on their
  rear with your main body; and victory will be assured。〃  It was
  thus;  he adds; that Chao She beat the army of Ch‘in。  (See p。
  57。)'
  48。  On open ground; I would keep a vigilant eye on my
  defenses。   On   ground of intersecting highways;   I   would
  consolidate my alliances。
  49。  On serious ground; I would try to ensure a continuous
  stream of supplies。
  'The commentators take this as referring to forage and
  plunder;  not; as one might expect; to an unbroken communication
  with a home base。'
  On difficult ground; I would keep pushing on along the road。
  50。  On hemmed…in ground; I would block any way of retreat。
  'Meng Shih says:  〃To make it seem that I meant to defend
  the position;  whereas my real intention is to burst suddenly
  through the enemy's lines。〃  Mei Yao…ch‘en says:  〃in order to
  make my soldiers fight with desperation。〃   Wang Hsi says;
  〃fearing lest my men be tempted to run away。〃  Tu Mu points out
  that this is the converse of VII。 ss。 36; where it is the enemy
  who is surrounded。  In 532 A。D。; Kao Huan; afterwards Emperor and
  canonized as Shen…wu; was surrounded by a great army under Erh…
  chu Chao and others。  His own force was comparatively small;
  consisting only of 2000 horse and something under 30;000 foot。
  The lines of investment had not been drawn very closely together;
  gaps being left at certain points。  But Kao Huan;  instead of
  trying to escape;  actually made a shift to block all the
  remaining outlets himself by driving into them a number of oxen
  and donkeys roped together。  As soon as his officers and men saw
  that there was nothing for it but to conquer or die;  their
  spirits rose to an extraordinary pitch of exaltation;  and they
  charged with such desperate ferocity that the opposing ranks
  broke and crumbled under their onslaught。'
  On desperate ground;  I would proclaim to my soldiers the
  hopelessness of saving their lives。
  Tu Yu says:  〃Burn your baggage and impedimenta; throw away
  your stores and provisions; choke up the wells;  destroy your
  cooking…stoves;  and make it plain to your men that they cannot
  survive; but must fight to the death。〃  Mei Yao…ch‘en says:  〃The
  only chance of life lies in giving up all hope of it。〃   This
  concludes what Sun Tzu has to say about  〃grounds〃  and the
  〃variations〃 corresponding to them。  Reviewing the passages which
  bear on this important subject; we cannot fail to be struck by
  the desultory and unmethodical fashion in which it is treated。
  Sun Tzu begins abruptly in VIII。 ss。 2 to enumerate  〃variations〃
  before touching on 〃grounds〃 at all; but only mentions five;
  namely nos。 7; 5; 8 and 9 of the subsequent list; and one that is
  not included in it。  A few varieties of ground are dealt with in
  the earlier portion of chap。 IX; and then chap。 X sets forth six
  new grounds; with six variations of plan to match。  None of these
  is   mentioned   again;  though the first is hardly   to   be
  distinguished from ground no。 4 in the next chapter。  At last; in
  chap。 XI; we come to the Nine Grounds par excellence; immediately
  followed by the variations。  This takes us down to ss。  14。  In
  SS。 43…45; fresh definitions are provided for nos。 5; 6; 2; 8 and
  9  (in the order given); as well as for the tenth ground noticed
  in chap。 VIII; and finally; the nine variations are enumerated
  once more from beginning to end; all; with the exception of 5;  6
  and